The UIS Prairie Stars finished seventh out of 15 GLVC member schools in the 2024-25 Great Lakes Valley Conference Commissioner's Cup standings, earning 71 points in the competition. UIS also placed ninth out of 19 schools in the GLVC All-Sports Trophy standings.

The Commissioner's Cup awards points based on a school's finish in GLVC postseason tournaments and regular-season league standings across eight sports: baseball, men's and women's basketball, women's cross country, men's and women's soccer, softball, and women's indoor and outdoor track and field.

The final Commissioner's Cup standings are:
1. Lewis – 90
2. Maryville – 83.5
3. Drury – 80
    Missouri S&T – 80
5. Missouri-St. Louis – 77.75
6. Indianapolis – 76.5
7. Illinois Springfield – 71
8. McKendree – 67.5
9. Truman State – 62.5
10. Rockhurst – 61.25
11. Upper Iowa – 45.25
12. Lincoln – 45
13. Quincy – 44.75
14. Southwest Baptist – 42.5
15. William Jewell – 32

The GLVC All-Sports Trophy recognizes the institution with the best overall performance across all 24 conference-sponsored sports, including associate members competing in bowling and women's lacrosse. Points are awarded based on finishes in conference tournaments and regular-season standings.

The final All-Sports Trophy standings are:
1. Indianapolis – 196
2. Lewis – 176.5
3. Drury – 167.5
4. Maryville – 156
5. Missouri-St. Louis – 148.75
6. McKendree – 145.5
7. Rockhurst – 136.75
8. Missouri S&T – 130
9. Illinois Springfield – 113
10. Truman State – 99.5
11. Quincy – 98.75
12. Southwest Baptist – 78
13. William Jewell – 71.5
14. Upper Iowa – 63.25
15. Lincoln – 62.5
16. Oklahoma Christian# – 7
17. Newman# – 6
18. Missouri Western^ – 5
19. Central Missouri# – 5

# Bowling member only | ^ Women's lacrosse member only